19 Mar 2015
TAM SEEN MANN ESTEFANIA v. CHAN NORMAN AND ANOTHER
- Citation
- TAM SEEN MANN ESTEFANIA v. CHAN NORMAN AND ANOTHER
- Court
- Court of Appeal
- Case number
- CACV187/2014
The Court of Appeal dismissed both appeals: the trial judge was entitled to find on the primary evidence (including video and contemporaneous documentation) that Mr Chan's cumulative conduct amounted to assault and that the Chans caused or allowed excessive noise constituting nuisance; the judge's injunctions and costs orders were properly granted; there was no need in these appeals to decide whether a distinct tort of harassment exists in Hong Kong.