Hong Kong Case Law: Decisions & Judgments | LexChat

Hong Kong Case Law

Judicial review (certiorari/mandamus)
  • 7 Nov 1977

    DAVID LAM SHU-TSANG v. ATTORNEY GENERAL

    Citation
    DAVID LAM SHU-TSANG v. ATTORNEY GENERAL
    Court
    Court of Appeal
    Case number
    CACV42/1977

    The statutory scheme comprising Magistrates' Ordinance ss.88-90 and the District Court Ordinance (notably s.6) must be read together and, by necessary implication, transferred indictable offences are to be tried in the District Court by a judge sitting alone; s.88 places a mandatory duty on the magistrate to transfer on the Attorney General's application and thereby abrogates the common law right to jury trial for transferred indictable offences; the Attorney General's exercise of that statutory discretion will only be set aside if unlawful or tainted by improper considerations; the Full Benc…