3 Mar 2009
JUMBO KEY HOLDINGS LTD t/a THE CLEARWATER BAY EQUESTRIAN & EDUCATION CENTRE v. HONG KONG EQUESTRIAN CENTRE LTD
- Citation
- JUMBO KEY HOLDINGS LTD t/a THE CLEARWATER BAY EQUESTRIAN & EDUCATION CENTRE v. HONG KONG EQUESTRIAN CENTRE LTD
- Court
- District Court
- Case number
- DCCJ4680/2008
The plaintiff proved ownership by sale agreement and the defendant failed to prove a general lien (no evidence of usage or express agreement), and in any event lost any lien by continuing to use the ponies for profit and by failing to give a definite amount or particulars; consequently there was no triable issue and summary judgment for return of the ponies was warranted.