Hong Kong Case Law: Decisions & Judgments | LexChat

Hong Kong Case Law

Non-building area
  • 11 May 2012

    ORIENTAL GENERATION LTD v. TOWN PLANNING BOARD

    Citation
    ORIENTAL GENERATION LTD v. TOWN PLANNING BOARD
    Court
    Court of First Instance
    Case number
    HCAL34/2012

    The Board's refusal to consider increasing the BHR beyond 130 mPD was quashed as arbitrary because the material before the Board did not establish that the permitted plot ratio/GFA (notably GFA from EVA and road setback equivalent to about 10 mPD) could be accommodated at 130 mPD, and both the 10 m NBAs and 20 m BG were quashed as arbitrary because the CO2 Air Ventilation Assessment relied on a narrow methodology that did not justify those specific dimensions; the restrictions lacked the cogent evidence required for measures that substantially limit development rights.

  • 11 May 2012

    ORIENTAL GENERATION LTD v. TOWN PLANNING BOARD

    Citation
    ORIENTAL GENERATION LTD v. TOWN PLANNING BOARD
    Court
    Court of First Instance
    Case number
    HCAL109/2011

    The Board's refusal to consider raising the BHR beyond 130 mPD was quashed because the material before the Board did not show that a 130 mPD BHR would permit full exercise of the site's development rights (including GFA from slope, EVA and road setback). The 10 m NBA and 20 m BG were quashed as arbitrary because the CO2 AVA compared only the options given by planning department without adequate exploration or quantification of alternatives, and thus provided insufficient evidential basis to justify those specific restrictions; planning restrictions must be proportionate and supported by cogen…