15 Jun 2005
LAW KIN WAH v. COMMISSIONER OF POLICE
- Citation
- LAW KIN WAH v. COMMISSIONER OF POLICE
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCAL99/2004
The court dismissed the application because (1) additional documentary evidence justified the AT's reversal to find guilt and the applicant had pleaded guilty to the charges; (2) the FDO had read and considered mitigation within the defaulter file so there was no illegality in confirming punishments; (3) M.6 was an administrative covering minute, not a staffing note, and non-disclosure produced no substantial prejudice; and (4) the DCP(Man)'s factual observations were within reasonable bounds and did not amount to material error warranting intervention, therefore no ground for judicial review…