7 Dec 2012
NGAN IN LENG AND OTHERS v. CHU YUET WAH
- Citation
- NGAN IN LENG AND OTHERS v. CHU YUET WAH
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCA388/2006
The court held that certain classes of documents relating directly to the Casa Real and Grandview transactions were relevant and likely to exist but limited disclosure was necessary and proportionate. For the Chu Summons the court found classes 10 and 11 were in Chu's possession/power and ordered discovery limited to those classes; other classes (including Subscription and remuneration/consultancy and drafts) were excluded as irrelevant, speculative or fishing. For the GR Summons against Kingston the court found a prima facie case of likely possession and relevance for specified classes but d…