12 Jul 2012
CHENG YU PIK LILIBETHE v. YAU YI KWONG
- Citation
- CHENG YU PIK LILIBETHE v. YAU YI KWONG
- Court
- District Court
- Case number
- DCCJ3436/2010
The court found as a matter of construction and implication of the parties' arrangement that profit shares were to be distributed after tax; the plaintiff failed to prove that disputed payments were bonuses independent of profit distribution or that she repaid the sums claimed; the HK$20,000 was a loan not a reimbursement, and therefore the plaintiff's claim was dismissed and the defendant's counterclaim for HK$172,898.80 succeeded.