6 May 2011
IAN HUNG WAI v. CHEUNG SAU KUEN AND ANOTHER
- Citation
- IAN HUNG WAI v. CHEUNG SAU KUEN AND ANOTHER
- Court
- Court of Appeal
- Case number
- CACV210/2010
The trial judge found on the evidence that there was no mutual commitment to marry and that the transfers were absolute gifts given out of love; loans and ring were not proved. The appellate court upheld those primary findings because the judge assessed the evidence as a whole, made permissible credibility evaluations, and there was no basis to conclude the findings were plainly wrong; therefore the gifts were not returnable and the claims for loans and ring failed.