24 Aug 2009
HO YUEN KI WINNIE AND ANOTHER v. HO HUNG SUN STANLEY AND ANOTHER
- Citation
- HO YUEN KI WINNIE AND ANOTHER v. HO HUNG SUN STANLEY AND ANOTHER
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCMP1009/2009
Leave to appeal was refused because the intended appeal lacked reasonable prospects of success: the judge properly applied the threshold for specific discovery by finding relevance and that documents likely existed; a lay meaning of 'brain disease' sufficed for relevance to alleged impairment; the temporal scope was a discretionary judgment for the trial judge; inference that donation/sponsorship records exist was open on the particulars; therefore no jurisdictional error or sufficient prospect to justify leave.