18 Jul 2024
LUI KWONG SHING trading as WAI SING ENGINEERING COMPANY v. PINE WOOD (F.E.) INTERNATIONAL LTD
- Citation
- [2024] HKDC 1182
- Court
- District Court
- Case number
- DCCJ3426/2019
Plaintiff failed to prove fulfillment of the 3rd Condition (95% completion by 25 Oct 2015) so no entitlement under the 2nd Contract; however the Oral Agreements (22 invoices) were enforceable and proved to be VOs performed by Plaintiff and payable in the net sum of HK$556,340.12 after deductions; Defendant failed to prove defects were caused by Plaintiff and its counterclaim for rectification costs is dismissed; interest and partial costs ordered to Plaintiff.