23 Jun 2023
LIU HON WONG AND OTHERS v. LIU CHEE KWAN AND ANOTHER
- Citation
- [2023] HKCFI 1658
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCA953/2017
Court dismissed all plaintiffs’ claims. Principal legal bases: plaintiffs failed to plead or prove a legally enforceable role/duties for D1 as Agent/Trustee/Helper (no pleaded consideration or estoppel); evidence and pleadings did not support inclusion of Lot 415 within helper duties; plaintiffs failed to plead and prove causation and the specific acts/omissions by defendants that caused the alleged losses (reinstatement costs, legal costs, undervalue lettings); disclosure of trust/tong documents is discretionary and plaintiffs failed to plead material facts and objectives sufficient to justi…