18 Jun 2012
LIU KEITH CHE MING AND ANOTHER v. POON CHI SING t/a GOOD VIEW ORNAMENT
- Citation
- LIU KEITH CHE MING AND ANOTHER v. POON CHI SING t/a GOOD VIEW ORNAMENT
- Court
- District Court
- Case number
- DCCJ2421/2010
Photographs disclosed in the defendant's lists of documents and referred to in a supplemental witness statement meant the plaintiffs were not unfairly surprised; the plaintiffs ought to have addressed the matter in their first witness evidence; accordingly the court exercised its discretion to refuse to exclude the photographs, refused to permit reopening of the plaintiffs' case, refused an additional supplemental expert report, and refused the subpoena; the plaintiffs were ordered to pay the costs of the application with a certificate for counsel.