25 Jul 2024
TSE DAO CHUEN 對 CHEUNG WAI YAN formerly known as CHEUNG SUET NGOR
- Citation
- [2024] HKDC 1150
- Court
- District Court
- Case number
- DCCJ1078/2020
The appellant's appeal is dismissed as filed grossly out of time without any reasonable explanation and on merits it lacks substance; the application to admit fresh evidence is refused because it fails the Ladd v Marshall criteria (no reasonable diligence, no likely material impact, credibility uncertain); and a restriction order is refused because the appellant's conduct, while dilatory and non‑cooperative, does not establish the requisite pattern or likelihood of continuing abusive litigation. Costs awarded to respondent as ordered.