Hong Kong Case Law: Decisions & Judgments

Topic

Return of documents

Legal area

Court

23 Jul 2007

WAI YIP UNITED MANUFACTURE CO LTD v. MASTERPOINT PROFESSIONAL LTD

Citation

WAI YIP UNITED MANUFACTURE CO LTD v. MASTERPOINT PROFESSIONAL LTD
Court

District Court
Case number

DCCJ777/2006

The court preferred and accepted the Defendant's evidence on credibility and factual conduct on a balance of probabilities, found no breach entitling the Plaintiff to refunds or indemnity, dismissed the Plaintiff's claims, and entered judgment for the Defendant on its counterclaim with damages (if any) to be assessed.
18 Feb 2005

FAN KIN NANG v. PROVIEW INTERNATIONAL HOLDINGS LTD

Citation

FAN KIN NANG v. PROVIEW INTERNATIONAL HOLDINGS LTD
Court

Court of First Instance
Case number

HCLA72/2004

The Court allowed the appeal because the Labour Tribunal failed to give sufficient weight to the substantial overlap and risk of inconsistent findings between the Tribunal claim and the District Court proceedings and because the matters were of such complexity that the Labour Tribunal proceeding should be transferred to the District Court (with a view to possible further transfer to the High Court).
24 Dec 2003

SAMUEL TAK LEE & ANOTHER v.CHAN KING SHEEN & ANOTHER

Citation

SAMUEL TAK LEE & ANOTHER v.CHAN KING SHEEN & ANOTHER
Court

Court of Appeal
Case number

CACV436/2002

The Court allowed the appeal, set aside the lower court injunctions and orders because the plaintiffs were estopped by earlier proceedings and this court's prior judgment which required delivery of the Part I documents, and because the plaintiffs failed to adducespecific evidence of privilege, confidentiality or likely misuse sufficient to justify an interlocutory restraint.

Hong Kong Case Law

WAI YIP UNITED MANUFACTURE CO LTD v. MASTERPOINT PROFESSIONAL LTD

FAN KIN NANG v. PROVIEW INTERNATIONAL HOLDINGS LTD

SAMUEL TAK LEE & ANOTHER v.CHAN KING SHEEN & ANOTHER