31 Oct 2001
LAU CHI WAN JAMES & OTHERS v. IP FOOK CHUEN THOMAS & ANOTHER
- Citation
- LAU CHI WAN JAMES & OTHERS v. IP FOOK CHUEN THOMAS & ANOTHER
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCA18995/1998
The appeal was dismissed because the Master correctly ordered specific discovery: the Schedule 3 and 4 documents are both relevant and necessary to determine whether defendants made payments of interest or capital after 9 December 1996, to resolve whether the plaintiffs fully paid their contributions, to ascertain the accounts arising from the HK$100 million sale (profit or loss) and to determine whether the purchaser was CCIL or NCIL, and thus must be disclosed.