17 Dec 1987
HOP FAT GRAMENTS FACTORY LIMITED v. SIBER HEGNER AND COMPANY (HK) LIMITED
- Citation
- HOP FAT GRAMENTS FACTORY LIMITED v. SIBER HEGNER AND COMPANY (HK) LIMITED
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCA6197/1985
Defendant failed to prove, on the balance of probabilities, that the plaintiff was liable for defects in a representative proportion of the goods or that the settlement with Puma was a reasonable quantification of the plaintiff's liability; insufficient evidence (no independent survey report, inadequately documented sampling and deficient expert evidence) meant the counterclaim must be dismissed and judgment entered for the plaintiff for the unpaid balance with interest and costs.