16 Apr 2013
BOLD SHINE INVESTMENT LTD v. TSUI YEE KWAN
- Citation
- BOLD SHINE INVESTMENT LTD v. TSUI YEE KWAN
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCA1867/1999
The summons for summary judgment was dismissed because the plaintiff demonstrated gross and unexplained delay in issuing the summons, the supporting affidavits did not comply with O.14 r.2 and O.41 r.5 and contained inadmissible material, and there were genuine triable issues of fact (notably denial of common intention and the defendant's pleaded loan and security) which made summary disposal inappropriate; a full trial was required.