30 Sept 2022
LIU CAIQIONG v. GOOD EXCEL PROPERTY CONSULTANTS LTD
- Citation
- [2022] HKCFI 2922
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCPI24/2016
On the facts established by CCTV, surveillance and contemporaneous records and by assessing witness credibility and expert evidence, the Court found the Metal Door only clipped the plaintiff's left heel causing minor laceration and mild soft tissue buttock/lower back injury; there was no evidence of the alleged door malfunction or of impact to head/neck; plaintiff's version was unreliable and overstated; plaintiff failed to prove defendant breached duties and in any event plaintiff acted unreasonably by stepping into the door's path (contributory negligence); claim dismissed and defendant awa…