4 Jul 2012
CHEUNG SHUI HAN v. DR LUK KA LING
- Citation
- CHEUNG SHUI HAN v. DR LUK KA LING
- Court
- Court of Appeal
- Case number
- CACV203/2011
The Court of Appeal held the Master's NLATO was made without giving IK the required opportunity to be heard and therefore was procedurally flawed; the Deputy Judge's summary imposition of a wasted costs order against IK without complying with Order 62 r 8 was also procedurally infirm, so IK's appeal (CACV 111/2011) is allowed. The Plaintiff's appeal (CACV 203/2011) is dismissed as the NLATO issue was not properly her concern and the Master's other costs findings fell within her discretion. The court affirmed that a NLATO can be equivalent to a WCO in substance but must comply with procedural…