24 Feb 1972
DONALD W. SHIELDS v. MARY CHAN (otherwise known as GING TAK CHOW otherwise known as MARY CHAN PO MAN)
- Citation
- DONALD W. SHIELDS v. MARY CHAN (otherwise known as GING TAK CHOW otherwise known as MARY CHAN PO MAN)
- Court
- Court of Appeal
- Case number
- CACV30/1971
The Appellant's occasional use of a small room for correspondence did not change the residential character or breach the Crown Grant or lease covenants; accordingly the refusal to grant renewal and order for possession and mesne profits was set aside. On the water charge, the trial finding that a nominal charge was agreed and that a bona fide dispute excused non-payment was upheld, so the cross-appeal failed.