17 Oct 2011
HORST JOACHIM FRANZ GEICKE v. 1-ONASIA LTD AND OTHERS
- Citation
- HORST JOACHIM FRANZ GEICKE v. 1-ONASIA LTD AND OTHERS
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCA2379/2009
The court ordered specific discovery because the Invoices were directly relevant to the issues in the action and the defendants had an independent obligation to disclose relevant documents despite the documents having been used in related matrimonial proceedings; absence of established privilege or valid reason to withhold meant no abuse of process. Conversely, the application for leave to adduce the matrimonial documents in this action was dismissed because r.121 MCR and the implied undertaking require the leave of the court seized with the matrimonial proceedings for inspection/use of mater…