6 Jan 2023
GOLDEN CONCEPT DEVELOPMENT LTD v. SUN DECO CONTRACTING LTD AND ANOTHER
- Citation
- [2023] HKCFI 68
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCCT30/2020
On the totality of contemporaneous documents and conduct the court implied a nominated sub-contract between PY and the 1st Defendant in the terms of the NSCtt despite no executed document; collateral contract and estoppel arguments failed; the Deed of Warranty was operative and bound the 1st Defendant; the Personal Guarantee was valid in principle but limited in scope to the Clubhouse works and the Plaintiff failed to identify recoverable loss under that limited coverage so recovery against the 2nd Defendant did not succeed; the 1st Defendant was in breach for lack of diligence and defective…