3 Apr 2003
CHAN HO WAN RICKY t/a HO WAN ENGINEERING AND TRANSPORTATION CO v. WONG CHUN KEUNG t/a C.K. ENGINEERING CO
- Citation
- CHAN HO WAN RICKY t/a HO WAN ENGINEERING AND TRANSPORTATION CO v. WONG CHUN KEUNG t/a C.K. ENGINEERING CO
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCA469/2002
The court rejected the existence of the alleged oral agreement on the facts due to inconsistencies in testimony, the drafting history of the written contract, absence of required documentary proof and the conditional nature of the alleged obligation tied to third‑party accounts; the written contract recording $24 per m3 was held to be the final price and the plaintiff's claim for HK$711,000 was dismissed.