14 Aug 2015
ANGLO-EASTERN SHIP MANAGEMENT LTD 對 LI SIU YAT
- Citation
- ANGLO-EASTERN SHIP MANAGEMENT LTD 對 LI SIU YAT
- Court
- District Court
- Case number
- DCCJ2580/2013
On the balance of probabilities the plaintiff failed to prove 10 of 14 alleged defects were caused by the tenant or were not ordinary wear and tear; four repair items were proved and awarded HK$4,250; the plaintiff had retained a HK$36,000 deposit which is offset against the award leaving HK$31,750 payable to the defendant; interest and costs were awarded to the defendant; the inadvertent disclosure did not prejudice the trial and did not affect the outcome.