19 Dec 2025
NORSHUHADA BINTI SHAHARUDDIN 1. ) Syed Faizal Shah Bin Syed Gulzar Ali Shah Sebagai Wasi Tunggal Kepada Harta Pusaka Dr. Zarina Bibi Bt Shah Mohd [Si Mati] [No. Mmc: 22471] 2. ) Dr. Mohd Daud Bin Yahya 3. ) Hospital Bersalin & Poliklinik Pu
- Citation
- BA-23NCvC-56-11/2022 (Mahkamah Tinggi)
- Court
- High Court
- Case number
- BA-23NCvC-56-11/2022 (Mahkamah Tinggi)
On the balance of probabilities the court accepted the plaintiff's expert (SP1) and contemporaneous records showing failures: inadequate continuous CTG monitoring, failure to obtain/record informed consent and risk advice, inappropriate use of vacuum, delay to perform caesarean and failure of hospital to ensure timely anaesthetist. Defendant1 and defendant3 were held liable; liability apportioned 50:50 between defendant1 and defendant3. No separate award for death of baby was allowed because claim did not plead damages for the baby; damages for maternal injuries and pain and suffering were aw…