20 Dec 2022
IDEAL INVESTMENTS LTD v THE EARTHQUAKE COMMISSION [2022] NZCA 641
- Citation
- [2022] NZCA 641
- Court
- Court of Appeal
The Judge correctly refused leave because the proposed class lacked a significant common issue: s 29(4) requires assessment on the facts of each claim and does not create a collective, date‑certain liability for all pre‑2012 earthquake claims; Ideal failed to identify any arguable legal or factual error in that finding and its proposed amendment would not cure the logical defect, so leave to appeal was refused.