The Court of Appeal held that grounds of appeal filed by Nzizera on 06/10/2022 and 07/10/2022 were timely as they were submitted within one month after the judgment copy was uploaded to IECMS. The High Court erred in holding Nzizera's claim inadmissible on the basis of res judicata, as previous judgments did not resolve the substantive issues raised. However, Nzizera failed to provide sufficient evidence to support his substantive claims regarding misappropriation of company funds, and the request for an audit was properly denied as it was not raised at first instance. No party was awarded co…
The Supreme Court found a 1997 extraordinary shareholders’ meeting invalid, awarded the claimants share value, unpaid dividends, interest, and legal costs, and granted review for injustice.
After repayment of the debt, Fundira Léon was entitled to the return of his 50% shares in PHARMAVIE Ltd. The subsequent transfer of all shares to VINE PHARMACY Ltd by Mutabaruka Cécile was invalid as it occurred after the order for rehearing. However, as the shares had already been transferred to a third party, Fundira Léon is entitled to the monetary value of his shares as assessed by experts, plus interest for delay, but not to dividends, as there was no evidence of distributed profits.
The Court of Appeal held that PASSAG COMPANY Ltd lacked standing to sue over funds belonging to ECOMIL-PASSAG Ltd because it had not obtained court authorization.
Registration in the company’s share register, not full payment for shares, determines shareholder status. There is no legal basis for a shareholder to unilaterally expel another shareholder; such action must follow procedures set by law or company articles. Kakoza’s expulsion of Nyagatare was unlawful, and Nyagatare retains his shareholder rights.
The Supreme Court held that shareholder status depends on registration in the share register, not full payment of shares, and that one shareholder could not dismiss another.