17 Aug 2015
SCHÄFER TOY CO GMBH v. LAM WING PING AND ANOTHER
- Citation
- SCHÄFER TOY CO GMBH v. LAM WING PING AND ANOTHER
- Court
- District Court
- Case number
- DCCJ2411/2013
The judge found both principal witnesses (Mr Schafer and Ms Lam) to be unreliable and their evidence contradicted by documentary evidence (emails, company records). Defendants failed to discharge the burden to prove beneficial ownership or the alleged oral agreements; plaintiff failed to prove the pleaded agency obligations and the claimed unpaid sums as commission. Consequently both claim and counterclaim were dismissed.