13 Dec 2017
LIQUIDATION COMMITTEE OF GUANGXI NON-FERROUS METALS RECYCLING CO LTD v. CNA METALS (ASIA) LTD
- Citation
- LIQUIDATION COMMITTEE OF GUANGXI NON-FERROUS METALS RECYCLING CO LTD v. CNA METALS (ASIA) LTD
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCA519/2017
The court accepted that mainland appellate judgments are final and conclusive for present purposes but found that the defendant s pleaded set-off raised a bona fide triable issue (including evidence that Top Lucky may have acted as plaintiff s agent and the mainland court s rejection was under appeal), so summary judgment was not appropriate; leave to defend was granted and the plaintiff s summary judgment application refused without prejudice to renewal after the mainland appeal concludes.