1 Dec 2003
GUARDIAN FIRE ENGINEERS & CONSULTANTS LTD v. LAW CHI SHUN t/a TECHNICOM ENGINEERING CO
- Citation
- GUARDIAN FIRE ENGINEERS & CONSULTANTS LTD v. LAW CHI SHUN t/a TECHNICOM ENGINEERING CO
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCCT8/2000
The court held that clauses 5(g) and 5(l) of the 18 March 1998 letter did not form part of the TOP1 contract; valuation findings were made on the disputed variation orders applying a 20% fatigue deduction to overtime, allowing higher supervisor overtime rates but disallowing unsupported meal/travel claims, accepting higher unit rates for certain sprinkler relocations subject to reductions for proven duplication, applying median valuations for disputed supplied materials (HKD 2,606,268 for TOP1 and HKD 1,482,387 for TOP2 after hoisting adjustments), finding TOP2 was governed by separate piecem…