26 Mar 2007
MAN SANG ENGINEERING CO LTD v. HUNG WAN CONSTRUCTION CO LTD
- Citation
- MAN SANG ENGINEERING CO LTD v. HUNG WAN CONSTRUCTION CO LTD
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCCT24/2006
The summons was partially dismissed and partially allowed: Item 1 denied as overly broad and fishing because it related largely to other subcontracts and build-ups not directly concerning the plaintiff; Item 5 was allowed limitedly — disclosure of percentage complete figures (Item 5A(1)) and Appendix A to the final account (Item 5B(1)) only; Item 3 was allowed but confined to the defendant's applications and supporting documents dated 10/7/01, 19/4/02, 20/6/02, 22/10/02, 7/11/02, 20/12/02 and 30/12/02 to permit assessment of the $2.2m credit for prolongation.