6 Apr 2023
WONG YU CHO, ROLLY AND ANOTHER v. ART STATEMENTS LTD AND OTHERS
- Citation
- [2023] HKDC 462
- Court
- District Court
- Case number
- DCCJ5763/2018
The court preferred the Relevant Defendants' factual witnesses and expert valuation over the plaintiffs'; the plaintiffs failed to prove existence of an interested buyer or a real/substantial chance of sale and failed to prove 28 thangkas were consigned; the Consignment Agreement was with the 1st defendant (not the 2nd defendant personally); the 1st defendant's counterclaim failed because the contract allocated responsibility for expenditures to the gallery and the defendant did not demonstrate total waste for all items; service on the 3rd defendant was not proved—therefore plaintiffs' claims…