22 Apr 2013
SAMLANE DEVELOPMENT LTD v. FUNG CHI FAI
- Citation
- SAMLANE DEVELOPMENT LTD v. FUNG CHI FAI
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCA318/2006
The court dismissed the application because the particulars sought were not necessary for disposing fairly of the cause or for saving costs under O.18 r12(3B); the Annexure I statement of account and disclosed supporting documents supply the fundamental particulars, the defendant's denials properly put the plaintiff to prove its case at trial, and further microscopic transactional detail held by accountants/auditors is evidential and for trial/discovery not particulars; costs awarded to plaintiff.