15 Oct 2009
CHUNG MEI INDUSTRIES LTD v. SO KWOK KEUNG
- Citation
- CHUNG MEI INDUSTRIES LTD v. SO KWOK KEUNG
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCA2604/2005
The Master’s refusal was varied: the first two interrogatories requiring disclosure of whether subsidiaries made profits and the amounts were refused as unnecessary and unlikely to materially assist the determination (if plaintiff's construction succeeds the profits are irrelevant; if it fails the plaintiff loses); the third interrogatory about the HK$4,931,348 intra-group balance was allowed as potentially relevant and proportionate.