18 Sept 2019
MASS OCEAN INTERNATIONAL LTD v. TRINITY HOLDINGS (HONG KONG) LTD formerly known as TREASURE DAY INC LTD AND OTHERS
- Citation
- [2019] HKCFI 2323
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCA691/2015
Consolidation of all five actions with consolidated pleadings was declined. The court held the TA Actions (HCA1295/2015, HCA1849/2015, HCA1850/2015) are sufficiently related to be heard together before the same judge (with HCA1295 as leading TA Action) and third‑party liability to be heard with them, but adverse possession issues in HCA691 and HCA694 are distinct and must be severed as AP Actions (with HCA691 as leading AP Action); the tenancy parts of HCA691 and HCA694 are stayed (without prejudice) and parties bound by findings in the TA Actions; existing pleadings shall not be expunged and…