28 Jan 2010
HUI YIN SANG AND ANOTHER v. TSOI PING KWAN AND ANOTHER
- Citation
- HUI YIN SANG AND ANOTHER v. TSOI PING KWAN AND ANOTHER
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCA392/2008
The court refused leave to amend to add the pleaded fraudulent misrepresentation allegations because the material relied upon (Cheng's statement) did not establish a prima facie case of fraud or reasonably credible support; the court refused leave for personal trust claims and estoppel by convention because they are legally and factually inconsistent with the derivative/double derivative claims, are bound to fail given separate corporate personality and the reflective loss doctrine, and offend O.18 r.12A where inconsistent cases are not pleaded in the alternative with reasonable grounds; the…