7 Mar 2005
TAI FOOK FUTURES LTD v. CHEUNG MOON HOI JEFF
- Citation
- TAI FOOK FUTURES LTD v. CHEUNG MOON HOI JEFF
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCA9932/1999
The defendant's applications were dismissed because the technical information and third‑party investigation files sought were irrelevant or unnecessary to fairly dispose of the dispute, the defendant offered no positive basis to show tampering (mere suspicion/fishing), sworn affirmations by plaintiff verifying completeness stand at interlocutory stage, and HKE advised the investigation file and recordings were destroyed; accordingly the summonses failed and the defendant must proceed to exchange witness statements within a fixed short period.