3 Jul 2007
SINCERE AIR-CONDITIONING CO LTD v. A.S. WATSON GROUP (HK) LTD t/a FORTRESS
- Citation
- SINCERE AIR-CONDITIONING CO LTD v. A.S. WATSON GROUP (HK) LTD t/a FORTRESS
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCCT53/2006
The application for summary judgment was dismissed because there are significant disputes of fact — including authorisation and scope of variation work, amounts charged, and defendant's set-off/counterclaim — that cannot be resolved on affidavit evidence alone and require live evidence and cross-examination, making summary determination inappropriate.