18 Aug 2025
On the balance of probabilities the defendants were 100% liable for the collision; plaintiff proven to be an innocent passenger and proved entitlement to special and general damages as quantified by the court.
27 Mar 2025
Court affirmed the Sessions Court: appellant failed to prove on the balance of probabilities both liability and quantum due to significant evidential gaps, inconsistent or unproven allegations of fraud and the failure to call critical witnesses or produce cogent documentary proof; accordingly the appeal is dismissed and the lower court decision is upheld.
20 Jun 2024
Plaintiff failed to prove negligence on the balance of probabilities: cause of fire remained indeterminate on the evidence, res ipsa loquitur inapplicable because requirements not met (not shown fire could not occur without negligence; no sole control by defendants; cause not established), tenancy clauses allocated fire precaution and indemnity obligations to tenants absolving landlord, and plaintiff failed to strictly prove claimed special damages; accordingly claim dismissed.
21 Jan 2021
On the balance of probabilities the 2nd Tenancy Agreement was entered into because Plaintiff's representative misrepresented authority of prior tenant; lodging a police report, not served and not followed by action, did not effect termination; Plaintiff voluntarily vacated and also breached the tenancy by using the land for office and living quarters contrary to Clause 3.06; Plaintiff failed to prove special damages with factual evidence; accordingly Plaintiff's claim dismissed and Defendants' counterclaim for removal allowed.