19 Jan 2026
LIANG XIAOZI v. TONG KWOK CHUNG (唐國忠), The Sole Executor to the Estate of Tse Yee Sun (謝致燊) otherwise known as Tse Chee Sun (謝致燊), deceased
- Citation
- [2026] HKCFI 363
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCA119/2020
The 1994 oral agreement did not exist; Plaintiff's evidence was not credible and was contradicted by contemporaneous documentary evidence and the conduct of interested family members in subsequent FCMP proceedings and settlement which treated the properties as part of the Estate; accordingly claims predicated on that agreement and on resulting constructive trust or proprietary estoppel fail; although the court has jurisdiction over equitable claims in personam, it will not exercise jurisdiction to order transfer of title (Prayer 3) because lex situs and inability to supervise enforcement prec…