6 Apr 2023
WONG YU CHO, ROLLY AND ANOTHER v. ART STATEMENTS LTD AND OTHERS
- Citation
- [2023] HKDC 462
- Court
- District Court
- Case number
- DCCJ1224/2018
The court preferred the Relevant Defendants' factual witnesses and expert evidence, found plaintiffs' evidence inconsistent and uncorroborated, rejected existence of the alleged buyer and the asserted loss of chance, found no credible basis that 28 thangkas were delivered (accepting defendants' account that 23/24 existed), held the 2nd defendant was not personally liable beyond his role as officer/agent, dismissed the plaintiffs' claims and the 1st defendant's counterclaim (because the consignment expressly allocated responsibility for expenditures and the counterclaim failed to prove wasted…