10 Jan 2024
WAH SUNG CONSTRUCTION & PILING LTD v. CHEERWIDE LTD
- Citation
- [2024] HKCFI 45
- Court
- Court of First Instance
- Case number
- HCCT57/2020
The Varied Contractor Agreement produced by Wah Sung/Alliance (including the Excepted List and Initial Approved Plans) was the true contract; it was not void for uncertainty. Many Additional Works were outside the VCA and authorised by Alliance and/or ratified or acquiesced in by Cheerwide (actual and ostensible authority), so Wah Sung was entitled to payment for agreed additional works (HK$34,300,469.25) and quantum meruit items (HK$730,533.70) together with levies, administrative fee, HD payments and delay losses. Cheerwide’s counterclaims against Wah Sung, Alliance and Chiu failed; Chiu ow…