The Supreme Court held that two final judgments over the same property were contradictory, set both aside, and ordered restitution of the purchase prices paid.
The Supreme Court annulled a commercial auction for failure to notify the owner and properly publish the notice, ordered restoration of the property, and awarded related compensation.
The Court of Appeal partly allowed the appeal, confirming restitution of USD 80,000 and damages, but reduced the interest calculation to USD 51,291 from 13 March 2021.
The Supreme Court held that motor-accident economic damages must use the BNR deposit rate, not the CBR, and ordered repayment of overpaid compensation.
The applicants failed to prove lawful acquisition of the property because the sale and transfer were not consented to or signed by both registered owners (spouses), nor executed before a notary as required by law. The registration certificate alone is insufficient when the underlying transaction is void. The property must revert to the original owners, and the applicants are entitled to restitution of the purchase price from the seller. No additional damages or compensation are awarded as the applicants contributed to the irregularity.
The Court of Appeal partly allowed an injustice review, ordering UNESCOM to refund Niyivuga Mansula 31,380,624 Frw as excess payment under the vehicle contract.